The Million Dollar Question: Second Mortgages vs. Cash-Out Refinance vs. HELOCs
When you’re trying to access the equity in your home, there are three main ways to do it: through a second mortgage, a cash-out refinance, or a home equity line of credit (HELOC). All three have their own pros and cons, so it’s important to understand them all before making a decision.
A second mortgage is basically a loan that’s secured by your home equity. The biggest benefit of a second mortgage is that the interest rate is usually lower than the rate on a HELOC or a cash-out refinance. The downside is that you’re still paying two separate mortgages, which can be a burden if money is tight.
A cash-out refinance is when you take out a new loan to replace your existing mortgage and then use the extra cash to pay off other debts or make home improvements. The biggest advantage of a cash-out refinance is that you can usually get a lower interest rate than you would with a second mortgage or HELOC. The downside is that you’re starting over with a new 30-year mortgage, which means you could end up paying more interest in the long run.
A home equity line of credit (HELOC) is like a credit card that’s backed by your home equity. You can borrow money as you need it, up to your credit limit, and then pay it back with interest. The biggest benefit of a HELOC is that you only pay interest on the money you actually borrow, so it can be a good option if you need flexibility. The downside is that HELOC rates are variable, so they could go up over time and end up costing you more than a second mortgage or cash-out refinance.
So, which option is best for you? It depends on your individual circumstances. If you need the money for a one-time expense and you’re confident you can pay it back quickly, a home equity line of credit may be the best choice. If you have a lower interest rate on your existing mortgage and you want to avoid paying two separate mortgages, a cash-out refinance may be the way to go. And if you need a lower interest rate and you’re okay with making two mortgage payments, a second mortgage may be the best option.
Whatever you decide, make sure you compare rates and terms from multiple lenders before making a decision. And remember, your home is one of your most important assets, so make sure you’re comfortable with the risks before taking on any new debt.
© 2025, Exuity