11964, Shelter Island, NY

The 11964 zip code of Shelter Island, NY has a median home value of $2,851,000. This is higher than the statewide median home value of $1,085,000 and the national median home value of $177,500. The 11964 zip code also has a high concentration of homes with a value over $3 million.

Shelter Island is an affluent enclave located on Long Island in New York State. The population density is low at only 1 person per square mile which contributes to the high home values in this zip code. Shelter Island residents are well-educated and have high incomes which contribute to the high home values. There are also a large number of luxury homes on Shelter Island which account for a significant portion of the overall home values in this zip code.